So your story is moving along fairly smoothly: characters are developing, plot is advancing, relationships are forming… when suddenly, BABIES! Or more specifically, suddenly, one of the characters turns up pregnant. Cue collective groans.
First off, this is the kind of decision that should almost never be made by the GM alone. If a player is having wanton sex without mind to consequences, a GM might be tempted to inflict pregnancy on them or their partners to make their life a bit more complicated. However, pregnancy and abortion are incredibly sensitive topics to suddenly inject into a social group, and it can cause unpredictable drama. If the GM feels the need to drop an Aesop on the Dangers of Unsafe Promiscuity, it’s generally safer to have the character be affected by social stigmas (or even contract an STD) instead.
That said, if GM or players really want to include pregnancy in their game, it can be a challenge to ensure it’s an engaging part of the story, rather than one that turns people off of it. Here are some dangers to keep in mind when navigating the minefield that pregnancy represents in tabletop games.
Pregnancy as Plot Device
There are a number of circumstances where a pregnancy is central to the plot of the story. For example, if the baby is the Magical Messiah that is prophesied to end the Thousand Years of Darkness (or conversely, if it’s the Anti-Christ who must be magically aborted before it brings about Armageddon), then it serves as the McGuffin for the characters to rally around or focus on.
Unfortunately, if one of the PCs themselves are the pregnant ones, this could unbalance the importance of the character in relation to the others. If it’s a small group or everyone involved in the game already agrees on it, there’s usually no issue. If it’s sprung on some of them however, it can be a bit unfair to many players that one of them is suddenly at center stage in the narrative.
On top of that, the pregnant character themselves may not be particularly overjoyed either. Traditionally in media, especially stories that involve a lot of action, women have been relegated to support or side roles far too often. When they do enter the limelight, it’s usually in one of the narrow roles defined by their gender rather than their individual identity. To put it plainly, the men are depicted as important because they’re strong or smart. The women are depicted as important because they have a uterus.
Even if the player previously agreed on their character becoming pregnant to serve the plot, they may eventually find it frustrating when they find themselves put in the box of “damsel in distress” by default. While it’s possible for a pregnant woman character to exhibit badassery by tapping into Mama Bear impulses, generally speaking they will be expected to stay out of harm’s way, as their life will be valued above others’, or artificially protected by Plot Armor.
And again, this might be something the character is perfectly fine with… but it shouldn’t be something that’s dropped on them unexpectedly. There is a depressing trend in gamer groups with only one female character or player where the “knocked up” plot hook keeps getting dropped on them. It might not seem like that big a deal at first, but being pigeonholed into a role gets old fairly quick for anyone… bad enough that female characters are so often expected to play social/support roles as it is.
Pregnancy as Plot Derailment
Conversely, if the pregnancy is NOT central to the plot, it often instead has the effect of a small moon entering a planet’s orbit, exerting forces that destabilize its trajectory.
Amidst all the major and minor story arcs, suddenly one or more of the characters are concerned with something that’s of little interest or importance to anyone but them. Not that there’s anything wrong with that per se, but having children often changes people, or at the very least shifts their priorities. In a small game this might not be that big a deal, but in a large one it can alienate the character or characters involved in the pregnancy from the others who are dealing with their own, more “public” subplots.
And then there are the effects of the pregnancy itself. If enough time passes in-game, there will start to be some inescapable symptoms (fatigue, nausea) that put the character at distinct disadvantages, unless you just pretend those don’t exist. Once the pregnancy begins to show, any sort of straining physical activity becomes difficult, and the character’s skill at fighting or running become effectively crippled. Many systems have built-in modifiers to reflect this, like taking negatives to rolls involving dexterity or stamina, and even ways to figure out whether the baby is harmed by events. After all, should a pregnant woman really be dungeon-crawling for treasure, or chasing down suspects for a shoot-out? And if they can’t, what can their character do during the months of inactivity that still lets them feel productive and engaged in the story? How will the party fare without them?
If you’ve read all that and are still determined to include pregnancy in your game, the most important thing to keep in mind is devising the right consequences for any outcome to make the pregnancy a compelling part of the story.
What if the character decides to have an abortion? Will there be a negative backlash from the father? Their society? What if they miscarry during some particularly intense physical interaction? Will they feel guilt and loss? How will it affect their future trysts?
What if they carry the child to term? Will they raise it themselves? Do they have the funds and time for that? Will they continue the adventure in the meantime, risking their lives and potentially orphaning their child? Will they give the child up for adoption? What emotional consequences will they feel?
To spice things up, think of the most interesting ways to introduce conflict, and make the characters struggle for their child’s wellbeing. This helps the parents (and their players) actually care about the “make-believe child.” For example, if the child is carried to term through strange circumstances or magical settings, how might it affect their well being? Do the parents need to find some ritual or potion to ensure their child’s health? Consider demonic/spiritual influences or magical “radiation” that might affect the child’s destiny.
If the mother or father are relatively famous or powerful figures in the world, how worried are they that their enemies will discover and try to strike at them through their child? Do they try to keep it a secret? What happens if the child is kidnapped? This is something the rest of the group might even rally around and assist in.
Again, caution is urged to have a care for player sensibilities: fantasy or supernatural influences aside, pregnancy and its assorted complications and consequences are all very real and traumatic events that can occur to people without even their friends necessarily knowing about it. With tact and care, it can be a compelling part of a story or character arc, but without it you might find certain players suddenly less interested in returning for subsequent games.